Food distributors and 3PL operators
Case 1 — Frozen and chilled distribution hub expansion
Regional food distributor adding 4,200 pallet positions across −25 °C frozen and +2/+4 °C chilled zones on an existing site. Budget band USD $2.5M–$4.5M.
Before
- Two informal quotations from contractors already known to the operations team, with different pallet assumptions
- No agreed design basis: storage temperature, throughput and door traffic were never written down
- Energy cost excluded from the comparison entirely, despite a 15-year hold on the site
- Programme slipping because civil works and refrigeration were being priced by different parties on different scopes
After
- 5 compliant proposals returned; raw spread of roughly 28% narrowed to about 11% after normalisation
- Two low bids had excluded floor heating and the electrical infeed — around USD $180K–$260K of scope
- Award on the second-lowest normalised offer, with a 3-year service agreement inside the base price
- Modelled annual energy roughly 14% below the incumbent design after evaporator and part-load optimisation
Sourcing approach
- Capacity and load fixed first using the warehouse capacity planner and refrigeration load calculator
- One RFQ pack issued to 6 pre-qualified suppliers: same duty, same racking density, same ambient design day
- Exclusions (electrical infeed, sprinklers, floor heating, commissioning) priced as named line items rather than assumed
- Bids normalised in the bid comparison tool, then scored on 10-year cost, not lump sum
ColdMatch RFQ timeline
- Week 0Scope intake. Capacity, temperature bands, throughput and site constraints captured in the RFQ builder. Warehouse capacity planner
- Week 1Design basis locked. Load and capacity outputs attached to the RFQ so every supplier prices the same plant. Refrigeration load calculator
- Week 1–2Supplier shortlist. 6 suppliers pre-qualified on comparable frozen-distribution references and local service coverage. Cold storage health check
- Week 2RFQ issued. Identical pack, identical exclusion list, identical response format and deadline. RFQ readiness score
- Week 5Bids returned. Clarification round closed; non-compliances listed back to each bidder in writing. Technical specification builder
- Week 6Normalisation. Exclusions priced in, bids restated onto one scope in the bid comparison tool. Refrigeration bid comparison
- Week 8Award. Technical compliance confirmed first, commercial decision taken on 10-year cost. Refrigeration TCO calculator
Calculators for this audience
Convert pallet targets into usable m³ and footprint before pricing anything.
Refrigeration load calculatorFix the kW duty per temperature zone that the RFQ is written around.
Refrigeration TCO calculatorCompare 10-year energy, service and spares instead of headline CAPEX.
Refrigeration bid comparisonNormalise exclusions so proposals are finally comparable.
